Are You Analysing Your Fund's Performance Correctly?

Are You Analysing Your Fund's Performance Correctly?

Friday, October 23 2026
Source/Contribution by : NJ Publications

On a Sunday evening in January 2026, Rohan, a 34-year-old software engineer from Pune, was scrolling through a fund-comparison app when one smallcap fund stopped him. It was ranked first in its category on three-year returns, with a number that looked too good to be true.

By Monday morning, he had made up his mind. He called Mehta ji, his family's Mutual Fund Distributor for over a decade.

"Mehta ji, this fund is number one. I want to move my savings into it."

Mehta ji didn't say no. He asked about cricket instead.

"Suppose you are picking a player for your IPL team. Player A scored 600 runs this season, but averages just 150 over ten seasons. Player B scored only 250 this season, but averages 500. Whom do you pick?"

"Player B. One great season doesn't make a reliable player."

"Exactly. Yet most investors pick funds on the basis of one great season."

"The number you saw is a point-to-point return," Mehta ji said. "It measures the return between one fixed start date and one fixed end date. It looks simple, but it has three problems."

Problem 1: Timing Can Mislead

"The first problem is timing," Mehta ji continued. "A point-to-point return depends entirely on its two dates. Change the end date and the number changes, even if nothing about the investment has.

"As on 30 September 2025, the five-year return of the Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI was 28.23%. The Nifty Midcap 150 TRI showed 27.47% and the Nifty 100 TRI 18.65%. Six months later, as on 31 March 2026, the same indices showed 16.34%, 17.50% and 10.30%. Same indices, same rules. Only the measurement date moved, and returns fell by 8 to 12 percentage points."

Index 5-Yr Return · Sep 2025 5-Yr Return · Mar 2026 6-Month Drop
Nifty 100 TRI (Large Cap) 18.65% 10.30% ▼ 8.35%
Nifty Midcap 150 TRI 27.47% 17.50% ▼ 9.97%
Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI 28.23% 16.34% ▼ 11.89%

Source: NSE | Past performance may or may not be sustained in future and is not a guarantee of any future returns

Problem 2: It Creates False Expectations

"The second problem is expectations," Mehta ji said. "Suppose you had seen 28% in September 2025. What would you expect from your investment?"

"Probably something similar," Rohan admitted.

That is the trap. Now imagine your fund gives you 15% a year instead. Over the long term, that is a healthy return. But measured against the 28% in your head, it feels like failure. You start doubting the fund, then the market, and one day you redeem. This is why many investors exit good funds at the wrong time. The fund did not let them down. The expectation did.

Rolling returns show what is realistic. Instead of one period, they examine every possible period within a long time frame. Daily rolling five-year returns from April 2006 to March 2026 cover more than 5,400 periods.

"Fewer than 13% of five-year periods in the midcap and smallcap indices delivered 25% or more a year. Across over 3,600 ten-year periods, none did. The median five-year return was 13.23% for large caps, 15.93% for midcaps and 13.25% for small caps. So the 15% that would have disappointed you is in line with, or above, what these indices have typically delivered.”

Source: NSE | Past performance may or may not be sustained in future and is not a guarantee of any future returns

Problem 3: Chasing Recent Winners

"But my fund is at the top today," Rohan said.

"That is the third problem," Mehta ji replied. "In a study of 19 smallcap schemes, the scheme ranked first on one-year returns and ranked only 14th on three-year rolling return consistency between December 2019 and December 2025. Investors buy the top fund after a strong run, often near its peak. Performance cools, they exit at a loss and move to the next winner. Each switch quietly erodes long-term wealth."

Scheme 1-Yr Point to Point Rank 3-Yr Rolling Rank What Happened?
Scheme A #1 ⭐ #14 ⬇️ Fell 13 places in consistency ranking
Scheme B #2 ⭐ #13 ⬇️ Also dropped significantly
Scheme C #3 ⭐ #7 ⬇️ Moderate fall in consistency

Note: Rolling return analysis: 31st Dec 2019 – 31st Dec 2025. Universe of 19 schemes. Source: AMFI

Numbers Are Only Half the Story

"Then what should I look at?" Rohan asked.

"Ask four questions," Mehta ji said. "Are the returns consistent across market conditions? How often has the fund lost money? How did it hold up in 2008 and the 2020 COVID crash? Does it beat its benchmark consistently?”

"A single point-to-point return cannot answer these questions. It only tells you what happened between two dates. Rolling returns, by looking at every possible period over a longer history, give a much better picture of consistency and long-term performance."

"But even the best analysis cannot pick a fund alone. The right choice depends on your financial needs, investment horizon, risk appetite, existing portfolio and how those needs change over the years."

That is where an MF distributor adds value. The distributor understands the investor's needs, sets realistic expectations, builds the right asset allocation and a diversified portfolio, then helps the investor stay with it through volatile phases, with regular reviews and rebalancing along the way.

"The fund is chosen once," Mehta ji said. "The journey is managed for years."

Conclusion

Many investors will recognise themselves in Rohan. Funds are often judged on a single point-to-point return, and schemes are switched whenever another fund tops the charts. What matters first is identifying the investor's needs, horizon and risk appetite. When it comes to analysing performance, rolling returns are a far better measure than any single number.

Invest with clarity, not just recent numbers.

Source: NSE, AMFI. Past performance may or may not be sustained in future and is not a guarantee of any future returns.

Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully. This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment or credit advice. Readers should evaluate their individual financial circumstances and consult their mutual fund distributor before making any investment decisions.

Imp.Note: We are registered NJ Wealth Partners and this interview published is sourced from NJ Wealth with due permissions. Reproduction of this interview/article/content in any form or medium by any means without prior written permissions of NJ India Invest Pvt. Ltd. is strictly prohibited.

© 2026 All Rights Reserved. Gaurav Sudhir Phadke AMFI- Registered Mutual Fund Distributor.
(ARN:171136 Date of Initial Registration: 07-01-2024 & Current Validity: 06-01-202).